Bright Works Review - SCPs

Bright Works RACI Chart & Roadmap » Bright Works Review - SCPs

This page serves as a working hub for collating reviews of all works authored by Bright, as detailed in Stage 2 of the proposal. See also: Bright Works Review - Tales/Other

Assess All Bright Works for Content
1. As a collaborative group, all works are checked for content, and subject matter;
  1. For each given work, authored by Bright, we should do the following:
    1. Read the piece, and note any problematic content specifically, with quotations;
    2. At a high level, note the subject matter included; (ie: if it is problematic, what about it? sexualization of minors? predatory tones? etc.)
    3. Tag the work as one of three categories:
      1. Problematic/To Be Removed; for works that are overtly problematic, and should be removed from the wiki;
      2. Ambiguous/Potential Removal; for works that are potentially considered problematic, and/or could be removed from the wiki, through this effort;
      3. Acceptable; for works that have no inherent problematic content. This does not disqualify the pages from being removed, if we decide to remove all pages; rather, this helps us know at a glance which works are more important to remove than others.
2. As a collaborative group, all works are checked for backlinks, and or significant contextual usage;
  1. There is already a list of backlinks in the policy-discussion thread; however, these are just urls;
  2. For each given work, any backlinks to the page should be checked for the following:
    1. How reliant is the work on the connected Bright work?
    2. Is the backlink minor, or is the inclusion major?
    3. Is the linked work problematic as well? Does it have thematic ties to the problematic work in question?
    4. If the backlink was removed, would it meaningfully affect the linked page? (Yes/No)
  3. Once all pages with backlinks are identified, we can quickly sort them into categories:
    1. Unrelated; for linked pages that have little connection to the work in question, if any;
    2. Related (Minor); for pages that have some contextual relation, but are either not problematic, or the inclusion in question is ambiguous;
    3. Load-Bearing; for pages that directly rely on the content of a linked work by Bright;

Works Authored By Bright

Current Progress: 63/63 Content Reviewed

Current Progress: 63/63 Backlinks Reviewed

Note: Bright is listed as having authored 65 total works by Crom; however, this includes both The Bright List and the associated redirect. As these both link to the Bright List Deletion Message, they are not included in this review.

Table of Contents

SCPs

SCP-029

Content

Problematic Subject Matter:

Pubescent girl not allowed clothes;
Female researcher who wants to give her clothes meets a horrible fate apparently;
She has the power to make men "pliant to her will";

Show Excerpts

Verdict: Problematic

Backlinks

Total Backlinks: 8/8

Backlinked Article: https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/fragment:project-isorropia-0

Administration and Management

Staff Information

Staff Utilities

SCP Wiki Links

05Command

SCP Wiki

SCPs