After a couple months of workshopping this, I feel Taylor's rewrite of the Criticism policy is ready to be voted on.
The proposed rewrite can be seen here
The focus of this rewrite was to make the crit policy more user-friendly and less intimidating to read in terms of wording. In addition, it was consolidated into more precise rules and guidelines for an easier understanding of expectations.
As this is a guide that is part of our required reading, voting on this thread is restricted to Moderators and Admins. Passage of this vote requires support of at least 60% of active mods and admins
Question: Shall the contents of the Criticism policy page be replaced with the contents of the above sandbox?
Voting template for sake of ease.
||~ Yes ||~ No ||
|| X || X ||
Voting shall be open for a period of one week.