Firstly, this idea is insanely tasteless, and I don't think it was a good idea at all.
However.
I don't like the idea of threatening to remove someone from the site for something they haven't written yet. Dexanote's original warning from the thread, and Bright's offer of a PM'd explanation, is excellent. However, the follow-up PM threatening to revoke his membership was over the line. Please note that we don't ban people for:
Writing shitty SCPs
This would have been, I think we can all agree, a shitty SCP. People would have torn this kid limb from limb. However, this is the exact same situation we had with Gargus over the Montauk Tale. He was spoken to, stepped back, and didn't post it.
I must strongly disagree with threatening banning over something that is not yet written.