Non-Disc Record - Vermillion Fenrir

Summary:

Excessively optimistic misleading feedback

Non-Disc Record - Vermillion Fenrir

Zyn 22 Jul 2017 06:36

Vermillion Fenrir does not match any existing user name has recently been giving quite a bit of overly positive feedback, which can be rather misleading especially on the forums.

Today in particular, they gave a glowing piece of feedback that resulted in an article being posted to the mainsite too early, and as such that article was taken down (due to downvotes, I believe). Thank you to Modern_Erasmus for bringing this to my attention.

+ show block

http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-2947287/scp-3119-shadow-woman#post-3488008

I personally find this very interesting. Mainly because there's hint of personal backstory and emotional note from her herself. […]
I find nothing to critique here. Though I'm curious on the reason behind her frequent random attack to the foundation. Surely this is some psychological subconscious reason and could be why she become "monster" at the first place? Anyway just throwing ideas here, not really feedback or critique.

http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-3090100/so-i-ve-got-a-skip-that-i-m-writing#post-3487982

Pretty interesting concept. A coffin that cause anomalous effect upon eye contact doesn't sound so unique, but causing one to cried to death, and only to be resurrected AND having their depression to be gone…. and then later replaced with PTSD.

Sounds pretty unique. Nothing too interesting for me, but it's kinda nicely executed.

http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-3090052/been-awhile-feeling-rusty#post-3488002 (the one that led to a premature post)

I was going to critique or provide feedback, but no. This is perfect in my eyes.

I need to admit, it doesn't pull much interest to me until I clicked the "Access Restricted to O5 Council" and…. Lord, this is the single most greatest thing ever written by the 05 Council. All to this day, many of us believed they're untouchable and cannot be harmed by anything… Then it was revealed that they're all corrupted in such way, and also as replaceable as the other agents.

Plus, it started with one of the most spine-chilling morally-intriguing words…

"Cold, not cruel."

Straightforward +1 rating is what I'll do. I demand this SCP to be a thing.

Given the sheer amount of cleanup that Forum Crit will need to do for this one, I've dropped a C&D here: http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-3061865/an-scp-i-ve-been-thinking-about#post-3491175 also PMed them. Keep an eye on.

Last edited on 22 Jul 2017 06:38 by Zyn Show more

Re: Non-Disc Record - Vermillion Fenrir

bittermixin 25 Jul 2017 02:46

For the record: this user has made another misleading/poor quality feedback here. The post in question can be found here.

Quotes:

because there does some SCP on the foundation that they wished to destroy IF possible, such as SCP-682 and this could potentially be a great cross-linking material.

The concept of the eye is all good, but the lackluster.

Modern_Erasmus has already made a Junior Staff Post warning the user about their suggestions.

Re: Non-Disc Record - Vermillion Fenrir

Zyn 25 Jul 2017 08:24

The problematic post linked above seems to have been made the same day the cease-and-desist was handed out, so I'm inclined to not have further staff action at this point.