Non-Disc Record - r2_bean2

Summary:

Immaturity, not following forum guidelines, might be banned on Discord

Non-Disc Record - r2_bean2

Zyn 31 Aug 2025 17:12

Noting for records-keeping that r2_bean2 (account age 109 days, site membership 100 days) has been messaging me recently:

+ show block

29 Aug 2025, 06:16 message subject "Can you green light my idea for 9kon"

Hello zyn.

I know you have other things to do so I will cut to the chase. I need reviews for my scp idea and I need them fast. I want to post for 9kon and I’m hoping that I can get reviews quickly so I can move to writing the actual scp. As I have found you to be one of the quickest reviewers, I hope that you see this message and and respond to it. I know how much time you spend on the wiki even though you are a volunteer. Here is the link to the ideas thread for my scp:
https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-17235252/seeking-green-light-9kon-the-cycle

Thank you for your time,
-r2_bean2

Sent back:

Sorry, I'm not familiar enough with the Church of the Broken God GOI to feel comfortable greenlighting this material. Have you tried swapping reviews with other authors in the official Discord?

30 Aug 2025, 06:05

First off, thank you for your time.
Second, did you think the idea was good even if you didn’t understand some parts.
Third, thank you for the discord idea.

Again, thank you for your time
-r2_bean2

I'm not familiar with the Church of the Broken God, so I can't say if the concept was good or not. You'd be better off asking someone who's familiar with the lore of that GOI and can tell you if what you're proposing is consistent with existing worldbuilding/themes.

31 Aug 2025, 08:57

Do you have any ideas of who to talk to. I’m trying to get discord to work but it doesn’t want to, so I would prefer people I can talk to on site.

Thank you for your time.
-r2_bean2

You can use the Tag Search tool: https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/tag-search to look up recently posted works that feature the Church of the Broken God, and reach out to the authors to see if they would be willing to read over your material. Please note that if your message does not contain proper spelling, grammar, and punctuation, readers may not be interested in reviewing the thread.

You can also try reaching out to other authors seeking reviews in the forums, to see if they think your material is good/if they would upvote the eventual page if they saw it on the mainsite.

Of note, the user has a forum thread here: https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-17144357/new-author-seeking-greenlight:new-scp:the-fear-parasite which originally did not use the proper concept critique template, and also has a thread bump. The user acknowledged this with a post: http://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-17144357/new-author-seeking-greenlight:new-scp:the-fear-parasite#post-7029270

[…]thank you for pointing out that bumps are not allowed. I am a first time writer after all and do not know all the rules.

thank you for your time and effort.

-r2_bean2

The user later posted another concept thread: https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-17162057/seeking-green-light:new-scp:hindsight and posted another thread bump on it.