Noting for records-keeping that
DUCKhunt555 (account age 1128 days, site membership 700 days) has been repeatedly messaging me about a concept they are seeking feedback on:
24 Jun 2024, 12:24
My article idea didn't work because it was just a thing that did a thing. I got feedback that there should an emotion of sorts that I'm trying to get out of the reader. I've seen other SCP's have a impending doom arc. Would that be a solution?
25 Jun 2024, 00:02
Sorry, I don't remember reviewing a concept from you. Did you mean to send the message to someone else? |
26 Jun 2024, 07:39
No it was you. It was about a radio receiver that could change the outcome of events.
26 Jun 2024, 23:25
I don't recall reviewing this material. Can you provide a link to the forum thread where I commented? |
27 Jun 2024, 07:37
It was via wikidot messaging.
27 Jun 2024, 23:01
I don't give full reviews in private messages. Are you asking me to post in the thread? |
28 Jun 2024, 07:49
Its this message.
28 Jun 2024, 22:48
Again, I don't give full reviews in private messages. If you're asking me for feedback, I would only be posting in a forum thread. Please link me to a forum thread if you would like to request feedback from me. |
I did some digging in my inbox, and found the following conversation chain from 10 days ago:
14 Jun 2024, 13:48
I'm trying to get the Greenlights needed for my SCP article concept.
Forum Post: https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-15074507/greenlights-wanted
Sandbox Page: http://scp-sandbox-3.wikidot.com/duckhunt555
15 Jun 2024, 00:11
Are you asking me for a review, or are you asking me for assistance finding reviewers? |
15 Jun 2024, 06:15
I would like for you to review it if that's possible.
15 Jun 2024, 09:56
My review would be negative and I would definitely not be greenlighting. With this in mind, are you certain you want critique from me specifically, instead of a reviewer who isn't as picky? You never responded to the current review you received. |
15 Jun 2024, 19:12
Ill try and look for a more specific reviewer, also that response was from a year ago so there is no point in responding now.
The thread in question is here: https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-15074507/seeking-greenlights-the-probability-changing-radio-receiver with the first post being from 5 Aug 2022. The user made a few revisions to change the post title and correct a typo.
The author received one review on 6 Aug 2022, which the user never responded to.
Almost two years later, on 12 Jun 2024, they posted a new comment to the same thread, with the exact same content as the first post, with no changes. They were told, "you haven't paid any attention at all to the feedback you've been given. You've literally ignored it and just copy-pasted the same idea. If you want people to help you, you have to actually pay attention to what critters are saying, otherwise other people will look at your idea and see no point in helping you."
The user then received another review on 16 Jun 2024, to which they replied with:
https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-15074507/seeking-greenlights-the-probability-changing-radio-receiver#post-6542206
Thank you for your feedback.
There are no new revisions or comments since that exchange.
Reviewers, might want to keep an eye out.