[[collapsible hideLocation="both" show="+ Show Long Post" hide="− Hide Long Post"]]
There are beautiful phrases in this poem. On the level of each sentence, however, it's difficult to say where one ends and the next begins. On the level of each line and stanza, this poem doesn't take the proper time to illustrate the scenes it's calling to mind. It doesn't give its images and feelings much space to impact the reader. There is little continuity of thought.
The poem doesn't seem sure if it wants to use vaguely Christian allusions, or personify nature, or discuss familial loss, or use metaphor to navigate mental illness. It touches on each of these, explores them without any degree of specificity, and then moves on. The poem simply never commits.
As a result, it isn't about any of these topics. I might say that what is evoked, is beautiful — just not in service to anything. It's like taking glances at small sections of a great big puzzle, and noticing interesting forms, but lacking sight of the connecting pieces that would compose the whole. Hence, it lacks cohesion.
I've read this multiple times now and still can't pinpoint what the message is. It's actually a bit frustrating. I also can't figure out what grammatical conventions were in mind because they vary all the time.
Here are a few examples of sentences that seem poised to relay a full thought, but never really do:
Darkness, skepticism, and dread permeating sadness, concealed from the heart by those who only know to see and breathe and believe
This doesn't make sense. It's all in the abstract; it doesn't connect to anything tangible.
Mornings, songs with inactive notes bringing the soul that is so alert to peace when the moon is obscured by the sun.
Taken at face-value, this is nonsense.
Where comforting warmth envelops the mind with visions of inspiration and hope to calm the spirit and let flowers flourish in the gentle rain, nurturing care, and quieting the voice of the storm
There is nothing here to latch onto. It's a run-on sentence. "[V]isions of inspiration and hope to calm the spirit and let flowers flourish in the gentle rain" doesn't point to anything specific. It pairs a real image ("flowers […] in the gentle rain") with the wholly generic ("visions of inspiration and hope to calm the spirit"). Maybe it's unfair that I connected the constituent lines as though they were one sentence. But look at the grammatical conventions: This is one sentence.
Pale echoes of nothingness in the mind who only recall the necessity and the difficulties
This has a glimmer of profundity, but at base, there is no meaning to extract.
Do you see what I'm getting at?
I'm very curious as to what meanings and thoughts the writer intended to relay. Unfortunately, I don't expect I'll find out, because I strongly suspect this was generated by an AI. Though, admittedly, I don't have evidence except vibes.