Making this a Disc thread as staff was recently alerted to potential sockpuppeting from this user on the WL site. Background is, the user posted a new page to the site, it received downvotes, and after the next round of applications, a bunch of accounts created on the same day with no other activity upvoted the page and posted defending it (and vehemently accusing a reviewer who posted a negative critique). All of the accounts were active within the same limited timeframe, and the comments posted share the same shaky writing/consistent errors (particularly with phrasing and apostrophes).
Details below. All of the sockpuppet accounts will be banned from the mainsite.
Goons_lake_girl http://www.wikidot.com/user:info/goons-lake-girl (upvoted Sinder's WL page, no other activity)
PatPat41 http://www.wikidot.com/user:info/patpat41 (the most obvious)
Posted comment in response to negative critique: http://wanderers-library.wikidot.com/the-viewer/comments/show#post-5172274
First off in a critique you NEVER put a value on something. with statements like I like or I hate or Strongly diss like like you kids say. you saying "This is not very good." is a value statement I would have thought this site would put a strong emphasis on that. Overly edgy? do you mean dark? and If so are you talking about the description of what was going on? if that's the case I can almost tell you with 100% accuracy why that is. (I use to screen write and teach it back in the '80s) this was to paint a picture, it wasn't meant to be dark. You misunderstood the point of why it's in the work in the first place. Lastly, you act as if you don't understand how humans work. (bare with me, my husband was in the army he did time in Vietnam so I think I get what Dr. Sinder was going for here). The privet was panicking and sputtering not being use to this situation. If I'm right he was in a historical mode and complaining trying to relieve stress. But his superior was calm cool and collected because he trained himself to be. That was VERY realistic. He wasn't outright telling him what their job was but was being sarcastic, probably irritated, and concerned for his well-being.
and for the "homicidal statue kill people" part I would guess that it was an act of revenge for "his treatment as a D-class" (whatever that is, look at his post on the review page.)
Your not understanding is making this pice fail. Next time remove your value statements and really dive deep into the work.
Granny out :)
Posted comment in one of Dr_Sinder's mainsite concept critique threads (which had also received negative feedback): https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-14414896/scp-xxxx-meet-the-family#post-5172148
I like this, I see what you're going for (I read the story in your sandbox) and it was good! The dialog needs some work but other than that it's not bad. From one seasoned writer to another don't let rude people get you down. Keep up the good work.
Posted comment on low-rated SCP coldpost in deletion: http://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/scp-6650-j/comments/show#post-5172157
+1 for me, take it from a granny writing isn't easy but it can be fun
Posted comment on a high-rated article with adult content: http://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/adult:scp-5706/comments/show#post-5172194
I like the story but my age is starting to show, Skyrim is that TV game right?
More accusing the reviewers on WL: http://wanderers-library.wikidot.com/the-viewer/comments/show#post-5172278
From one screenwriter to another don't let assholes get you down(I was a woman screenwriter in the 80s '90s and early 2000s trust me when I say I've seen all types, I can see why you thought he was rude he acted as if he had a bad day and took it out on you).
Lady_Black http://www.wikidot.com/user:info/lady-black
Posted comment in response to another sock, about 30 minutes after: http://wanderers-library.wikidot.com/forum/t-14420069/the-viewer#post-5172288
I was going to give it a -1 but I saw Granny's post and damn she knows her stuff she opened my eyes for sure!
Wrongturn89 http://www.wikidot.com/user:info/wrongturn89 (upvoted Sinder's WL page, posted a comment on another WL page within 10 minutes of the Lady_Black sock comment)
Heal_Yourself_86 http://www.wikidot.com/user:info/heal-yourself-86
Posted comment in response to another sock, about 15 minutes after: http://wanderers-library.wikidot.com/forum/t-14420069/the-viewer#post-5172279
I want to echo what was already said I thought this was an interesting concept!
Token_Blain86 http://www.wikidot.com/user:info/token-blain86 (upvoted Sinder's WL page, posted a comment on another WL page within 5 minutes of the Heal_Yourself_86 sock comment)
