Non-Disc Record - Dr Kenyon

Summary:

Unhelpful critique

Dr Kenyon

Zyn 01 Apr 2015 03:38

New site user Dr Kenyon has recently given some unhelpful feedback. I've sent them a PM with the usual cease-and-desist.

http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-1161546/scp-xxxx-gray-old-god-ain-t-what-he-used-ta-be#post-2261611

I like its weirdness but it is painfully short and not detailed enough. Remember you are a scientist you should treat this like a scientific analysis. You wrote it more like an essay.
Again Great idea poor execution keep working on it buddy.

On a coldpost currently at -20 (note that the subject line was "Buddy listen…") There may have been other questionable posts on now-deleted articles.

Dude there is no meat to this post. Remember you're a scientist and your recording a paranormal creature.
Also this creature with this limited information is kinda uninteresting you should rework this and post a new draft to the drafts and critiques forum to get feedback before trying to become official.
I think you can do it but take your time. I'm working on an SCP too and i spent about 5 hours collectively on it and its still not ready.

And just to note, they've been derping around a bit with ways to terminate 682 (both of these are comment chains):
http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-1093854/scp-2322#post-2260528
http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-76858/scp-682#post-2260504

Keep an eye on them.

Re: Dr Kenyon

Zyn 03 Apr 2015 21:24

And now they're flailing a bit on a comment in coldpost's discussion thread:

First comment from Dr Kenyon

{This isnt a review} How would an object created by the big bang end up on earth? we are not the center of the universe… though technically everything is.

Reply from Kalinin

Nothing about your post makes any sense, including the pointless "this is not a review" disclaimer.

Reply by Dr Kenyon

I am no astrophysicist but i'm pretty sure the Big Bang Theory is the theory that the universe was once a single point in existence and the it exploded and expanded outwards creating the universe. also I put the not a review thing because I didn't want Zyn to think I was reviewing.

Reply by Kalinin

Your first sentence isn't really relevant to anything that's been said thus far. Here's why this doesn't make sense:

How would an object created by the big bang end up on earth?

This doesn't even seem to relate to the article, since the object in question, for some reason, is theorized to have caused the Big Bang, not be a product of it. Aside from that, your statement presumes that there are indeed individual objects that were "created" by the Big Bang and that they behave in a certain way that would preclude them from being on Earth for some reason. I can go further in explaining why your presuppositions leading you to make that statement make no real sense if you really want.

though technically everything is.

I have no idea what you're inferring with that. Everything is technically the center of the universe? Huh?

Also, my word isn't official here, but generally, if staff asks you to stop reviewing things, that usually includes what you're doing here. When you comment on something about the article and question it being there, you're reviewing it. And in this case, your review doesn't make any sort of sense.

Reply from Dr Kenyon

Dude i'm not a scientist so i'm not gonna fight with a weapon I can't use so you win ok.
Zyn told me not to review until I post a successful article not because I did something bad and it was a question.

Closed Staff Post by Eskobar

What Kalinin is trying to say is that every comment on an article is a review of it, including one-line questions of the internal logic or consistency of the SCP. If you just have a random question or comment to make of the author, you can PM them or come into chat and see if someone can help you. But once you're making a post on the discussion page, all of those posts are supposed to serve to improve the article — i.e., a review.

I'm closing this thread of conversation because it seems to be spiraling a bit. Dr Kenyon, Zyn's order still stands.

---

They still don't seem to understand what's going on. Revoke on next infraction.

Last edited on 03 Apr 2015 21:25 by Zyn Show more

Re: Dr Kenyon

Zyn 04 Apr 2015 18:10

Aaaaand replied to a closed staff post: http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-1161342/my-first-scp-idea-please-review#post-2263839

Moving for revocation.

Re: Dr Kenyon

RJB_R 04 Apr 2015 18:13

Voting in favor of it

---

Whether you like it or not, history is on our side. We will bury you!

Re: Dr Kenyon

AdminBright 04 Apr 2015 19:39

Agreed.

---

Admin, SCP Wiki

Re: Dr Kenyon

Drewbear 04 Apr 2015 19:49

Revoked and the following message sent:

+ show block

Hello, Dr Kenyon;

Your membership to the SCP Foundation wiki has been revoked at this time due to apparently not understanding the site rules. This is not a ban and you are free to reapply in 24 hours, but we strongly recommend re-reading the Site Rules and Newbie Guide pages and re-familiarizing yourself with the behavior we expect from our members. The O5 thread regarding this is linked below.

Admin Drewbear

http://05command.wikidot.com/forum/t-1161553/dr-kenyon
http://www.scp-wiki.net/site-rules
http://www.scp-wiki.net/guide-for-newbies

---

Giving bearhugs to the unsuspecting since 1872.