Non-Disc Record - Alex Kaster

Summary:

Unhelpful feedback, vehement response to negative feedback

Alex Kaster

Zyn 17 Mar 2015 04:12

Site member Alex Kaster has been giving out very misleading feedback in the forums. The following were staffposted on:

http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-1148749/my-first-scp#post-2251480

Pretty good work here. You do have grammar and capitalization problems, but if you simply use the spellchecker, all will be fine here. You could make this more interesting, but you're already working on that.

http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-1149369/my-scp-2247#post-2252142

Doing well for the concept, but what's the story about this SCP? All I know is that it came from a old house. Besides that, I believe you're fine

The latter of which was a closed staffpost and a cease-and-desist. I sent them a PM as well, revoke on next infraction.

Re: Alex Kaster

Zyn 18 Mar 2015 23:53

Recently they had a piece deleted, and they reacted by posting the following to their initial draft forum:

http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-1148769/dead-forest-draft#post-2253115

Well, I'm deleting this. Due to no feedback, I had to cold post it, and the result was a instant failure. Thanks a lot, 'community'.

They also edited a previous post to state: http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-1148769/dead-forest-draft#post-2251473

No more of this. I give up this project because the supposedly helpful community couldn't help, besides Zyn and Decibelles.

Edit: Wouldn't help

I told them to calm down and use the chat, but if they start lashing out like this again, official warning.

Re: Alex Kaster

Zyn 23 Mar 2015 00:27

Today they posted an article again, and after it was downvoted, they changed the title to "Dead" and the source text to the following:

This is Dead. Please stop reading, and go read something more interesting than the original junk posted here…

Re: Alex Kaster

Sophia Light 23 Mar 2015 00:37

Official warning? This seems pretty similar to the last incident (immature reaction to undesired response). I can send one if desired.

Re: Alex Kaster

Zyn 23 Mar 2015 01:30

Yeah, I say official warning. As far as I can tell, that "dead" page is still up.

If you could send it, that'd be awesome.

Re: Alex Kaster

Sophia Light 23 Mar 2015 07:31

Sent.

+Show warning

Alex Kraster, you replaced the text of a poorly rated SCP you wrote with the following: "This is Dead. Please stop reading, and go read something more interesting than the original junk posted here…"

This is not an adult response to feedback. The Deletions Guide clearly lists how to delete your own work, and you apparently didn't even try to do this. Given that you have already been warned about immature reactions, this is an official warning. Further immaturity may lead to a ban. If you have any questions, please tell me or another member of staff.

-Sophia Light

Deleted the article, also.

Re: Alex Kaster

Crayne 23 Mar 2015 08:03

This is not an adult response to feedback.

Thank you for adding this, as it's the crux of the problem here. With just the message that they're being warned, it's often hard for members to figure out exactly where they went wrong.