Site Criticism Team Hub

THIS PAGE IS ARCHIVED

The information here is not up-to-date and may be inaccurate.

It is preserved for historical purposes. Please avoid editing this page.

This page has been deprecated. Please see http://05command.wikidot.com/critique-main for the new unified Critique Team hub.

---

Overview and Responsibilities

The Site Criticism Team is the staff team of the SCP Wiki concerned with providing critique to published articles on the site. Additionally, it is their responsibility to ensure critique on published articles are kept up to standard. More specifically, the Site Criticism Team's responsibilities are:

• Responding to posted articles, and attempting to ensure no posted article (SCP/Tale/GoI Format) goes without critique.
• Keeping criticism at an acceptable level of quality by preventing dogpiling and countering bad advice with stronger ideas.
• Reporting continued criticism policy violations to the Disciplinary Team.
• Assisting the Rewrite Team by giving suggestions for improvement on articles.
• Maintaining How To Write An SCP in conjunction with the Forum Criticism Team.
• Proposing changes to other existing guides or documentation as necessary, particularly the Criticism Policy.

This team is only responsible for published articles. The team responsible for forum critique is the Forum Criticism Team, mentioned prior.

If you have any questions or concerns, please inquire in #thecritters or message a member of the team.

List of Staff Members

Team Captains
Riemann
ManyMeats

Vice Captain
Meserach

Active Staff Members
DrAkimoto
fabledtiefling
gee0765
Marcelles_Raynes
Pedagon
tawnyowljones
UncertaintyCrossing

Junior Staff Members
AnAnomalousWriter
Doctor Fullham
Dr Whitney
IronShears
JakdragonX
Mew-ltiverse
Mooagain
PlaguePJP
R4_EX
WizzBlizz

Administrative Contacts
Zyn (Primary Contact)

Inactive/Reserve Staff Members
Hexick
MalyceGraves
SoullessSingularity
TheMightyMcB

Site Criticism Team Structure

~ We endeavor to provide useful, helpful criticism in order to help writers improve their projects on the site. ~

---

This is our mission statement, and it is important that this is kept in mind in every member. What will be posted on this page are responsibilities as well as useful links.

Members of this team are expected to:

1. Endeavor to accomplish at least five reviews per month, with more active members strongly encouraged to set higher goals for themselves. Priority will go to new articles and articles currently under review.
2. Provide occasional feedback to critiques. This is recommended to be done through PM or with a reply stating agreement and reasons to agree. It is also important to correct when someone else isn't critiquing well.

Members of this team are recommended to:

1. Set goals for themselves based on activity level.
2. Report to a Discipline Team member if a user is continuously out of line.
3. Regularly visit the official channel and discuss topics as necessary.
4. Provide feedback/suggestions to the captain as necessary.
5. Visit, read over, and perhaps use this handy guide on criticism.

Useful Links

Please PM a team captain for suggestions! Use these links to either link to newbies when necessary or as a general addition to critique.

• This Handy Criticism Guide
• General Writing Resource Thread (Additions are welcome!)
• Avoid The Blackbox
• How To Be Scary Without Saying Anything
• Mobile Task Forces
• Object Classes
• Secure Facilities Locations
• Security Clearance Levels

^{If there are issues with this page, please contact a member of the Maintenance and Ancillary Staff Team.}