New site member Communism Chicken does not match any existing user name (account age 14 days, site membership 13 days) has recently demonstrated a few problematic behavioral issues. Thank you to Jazstar for compiling this list:
- Asked for feedback on a draft and then discarded it when faced with negative feedback: http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-5967379/here-she-is
- Complained about how poor a writer they were on IRC (I believe it was in response to a negatively received coldpost, though I'm not certain), and then left chat midway through a number of users offering advice and encouragement.
- Asked a user for feedback on IRC and then left after I [Jazstar] asked them whether this was their third SCP in a week. Note that I actually had a long conversation with the user in private immediately after this, explaining how they were developing a bit of a reputation, how to respond to feedback, how to try and change their reputation (e.g. apologise to the critter in chat and explain that feedback was hard for them), how to help deal with feedback, etc. I got the impression that they were just an excited user with lots of ideas and no confidence.
- Starting a second thread in the drafts forum less than a week after the first: http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-5992558/unexplained-location-needs-crit-for-now
- One week ban in chat for abusing pronoun-bot: http://05command.wikidot.com/forum/t-5992576/communismchicken
- Providing low-content feedback on a draft, and continuing to do so even when explicitly asked by the author to expand on what they meant: http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-5992591/the-eastern-grandma-j
The feedback in question was across a few posts:
http://www.scp-wiki.net/forum/t-5992591/the-eastern-grandma-j#post-3811742
It would be cool if you use the number as the same as "Baba Yaga" for the -J. There is a lot of wording and grammar issues in this, so if you would like through it I would personally appreciate it if you fix it. Other than that I personally find it funny. Have fun with this.
I would just look through and see. You will definitely see them just look through thoroughly and you will find them.
It's still not written very good. I like the idea and it is still funny. Make sure to ask others about wording and you will succeed.
I dropped a C&D at that point, since this is the sort of feedback that actively harms the quality of new authors' work (and also leads to a fair bit of frustration on both the authors' and reviewers' part).
Keep an eye on.