Noting that DarkShadow7373 has a history of giving problematic feedback: http://05command.wikidot.com/forum/t-14192922/non-disc-record-darkshadow7373
As of yesterday, they posted an extremely unhelpful comment that resulted in the author angrily giving up on the thread. This is not the first time they've been addressed for being excessively vehement/going off on tangents instead of helping the author.
As such, I have dropped a cease-and-desist order here: https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-14202523/crits-requested#post-5090852 and PMed the user noting that they are now no longer allowed to post critique in the Writing Help forums until they've written a successful mainsite article.
ETA: noting that I received a reply to the PM
I will try to work on my tone more. Can I get a second chance maybe?
Replied noting:
| You can still post feedback in mainsite page discussion threads (just not the threads in the Writing Help forums). Please note that it's not just your critique tone that needs work—you need to better explain to authors why certain material is frequently downvoted and why you don't like certain material, and try to offer non-generic suggestions for improvement. |
