User mr-ade does not match any existing user name (W:6d | S:5d) has a history of providing low quality, often very negative feedback.
There's a general tendency throughout these for them to highlight relatively minor details as if they're the main issue (e.g. in the first thread, they focus entirely on "When 5 people enter it" without providing any additional feedback beyond 'you need to elaborate and explain more'; or in the final thread they highlight the carnivorous nature of the squirrels as being 'absurd and common' without really explaining why either is the case).
Would probably recommend a quick PM warning about this, with a C&D from providing critique in the forums if this behaviour continues.