Non-Disc Record - winkwonkboi

Summary:

Backseat modding.

Non-Disc Record - winkwonkboi

The Pighead 08 Mar 2021 15:25

User winkwonkboi (Wikidot user since 387 days, site member since 384 days) have made some backseat modding.

This one, who is from February: http://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-13994544/my-scp-idea-draft#post-4890817

+ show

Author, this is the Ideas Critique Forum. You are not to have a draft as your thread. Please go to this link as well as this one to know how to properly use this forum.

If you still wish to receive feedback on your draft, please go to the IRC Chatrooms.

And today, they've posted these two comments in a short amount of time.

This one, in response to a user who posted a full draft: http://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-14021932/devil-s-heart#post-4920291

+ show

Author, as per draft forum policies, all first-time authors must have their concepts reviewed and greenlighted by two experienced reviewers. If you still seek for draft critique, please ask in the IRC chatrooms.

If you have received the necessary requirements, please edit your comment containing the link to your sandbox containing said draft as well as the link to your greenlights. Posting whole drafts onto one comment is not supported.

And this one, in response to a rude crit made by another user: http://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-14021336/scp-5527#post-4920366

+ show

Okay, while we all agree that criticism is necessary to polish up our ideas/drafts/final products, that doesn’t excuse you for how you presented it. I looked through your feedback and I overall agree with what you are saying. My problem here is that the way you wrote it down came off as rather rude.

As per criticism policy, there is a line crossed between being harsh while meaning no mean intent to being straight up mean, and I think you’ve crossed that line.

You’ve also broke the one rule located in the guide for newbies, which is:

Don’t be a dick.

TLDR: Don’t write such problematic critique, no matter how helpful they may be.

I've staffposted in the last discussion thread. Keep an eye on in case it becomes a pattern.

Last edited on 08 Mar 2021 15:29 by The Pighead Show more