Putting this in disciplinary since it's treading close to a revoke.
HoboTriangle (formerly SirHoboTheTriangular, account age 25 days, site membership 18 days) recently posted a rather vehement response to feedback in the forums: http://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-14008037/a-cavern-that-houses-various-luxurious-ores-minerals-and-gem#post-4904138
[…] Also bear in mind, this is an idea concept, i cant exactly flesh out my entire idea in 400 words believe it or not, and you ask why does the cave collapse all of a sudden, it's an scp, the cave is APART of the scp. Not just the wendigos, and how the hell am I being insensitive to the folklore, sure people do have a popular mental image of the wendigo, but it's appearance is mostly subjective. […]
I always love feedback dont get me wrong, but this feels just like bluntly insulting an idea, rather than an actual critique.
And a main aspect of making an scp is to leave the more mysterious parts out and making it more intriguing for readers, you however, just want literally every detail layed out in front of you being as concise and explained as possible, completely defeating this purpose, at all. This isnt a review, its just insulting the idea.
Also, noting that their profile image seems to be from hentai manga. I believe we should ask them to change that.