So… I kind of wish someone had made it clearer to me that we were intent on pursuing disciplinary action for this, because last night I informed CorpseofBixby that she would be required to post a public apology and the next infraction would be grounds Dr immediate dismissal from the Butterfly Roster.
I personally feel like there was no malice involved in this (just extremely bad judgment and probably too much reading of the crackfic contest works? I'm pretty sure most authors for those pieces didn't seek permission for using site member names, nor did they check for age of consent) so an immediate perma feels like jumping the gun given how easy it is to misinterpret the precedent.
Granted, I haven't read the draft and I am inherently biased since CorpseofBixby has responded well when handling instructions on how to improve their feedback, and seems genuinely devoted to contributing to the site. If the parties involved would like to pursue disciplinary action, I have no issue with that.
We definitely should write up clearer policy on adult works, but given that this just seems like a dumb mistake, I don't think immediate perma makes sense. Month ban, 6 month ban maybe.
At any rate I think it's best that I recuse myself here since I don't think I'm entirely impartial. But these are my thoughts about the matter.
ETA: upon further investigation of the context and the messages I have been sent with concerns, I have removed CorpseofBixby from the Butterfly Squad Roster. It's unfortunate since she is one of the most active respondents in the forum, but this is not behavior we want associated with the most trusted reviewers on the site.